Spices and flavor
Umami: fish sauce, miso, soy sauce
In a nutshell Fermented seasonings bring glutamate but also a lot of salt; count them as salt, and stir miso into the soup only off the heat.
Why
During long fermentation of soya, grain or fish, proteins break down into free amino acids, above all glutamate, which the tongue perceives as umami, a savoury fullness of taste; nucleotides from meat, fish, dried mushrooms or from fermentation multiply this sensation, so a small amount of fish sauce or soy sauce deepens the flavour of the whole dish. These seasonings are above all salty, though: according to the US FoodData Central database, fish sauce contains roughly 20% salt, soy sauce about 14% and miso about 9%, so they replace part of the salt rather than add to it (Salting and seasoning card). Fish sauce and soy sauce tolerate boiling and their flavour rounds out in a long-simmered sauce, but the salt concentrates as it reduces; miso, by contrast, loses its delicate aroma with longer boiling, so it is mixed into a little warm stock and stirred into the soup only after it comes off the heat. Many of them contain allergens that must be declared on EU labels: soy sauce and miso contain soya and often wheat or barley, fish sauce fish, oyster sauce molluscs and shrimp paste crustaceans.
How to do it
- Count fish sauce and soy sauce as salt: a tablespoon of fish sauce carries about 3.5 g of salt, a tablespoon of soy sauce about 2.2 g; add the recipe salt only after tasting.
- Add fish sauce or soy sauce to long-simmered sauces and stocks in portions and adjust the seasoning only at the end, when the dish has its final consistency.
- Mix miso into a ladle of warm stock and stir it into the soup off the heat; after that only keep the soup hot, do not boil it.
- If a dish with fish sauce is salty but flat, add acid and a little sugar, such as lime and palm sugar, not more salt.
- Look for allergens on the label: soya and gluten-containing grain in soy sauce and miso, fish in fish sauce, molluscs in oyster sauce; treat tamari as gluten-free only if labelled so.
- Store opened seasonings as the label says, miso and oyster sauce in the fridge; miso keeps longer if you use a clean spoon.
If it goes wrong
Dilute an over-salted dish with unsalted stock, water or coconut milk and add more unsalted ingredients, or serve it with unsalted rice (Salting and seasoning card). Lime juice, a little sugar and fresh herbs soften an overly strong fishy taste. Whisk grainy miso in soup smooth or strain the soup through a sieve, and next time mix the miso separately; a spoonful of miso stirred in off the heat restores the aroma of an over-boiled soup, but only if the soup can take more salt.
Recipes using this technique
Sources
- USDA FoodData Central: Sauce, fish, ready-to-serve (FDC 174531)
- USDA FoodData Central: Soy sauce made from soy and wheat (shoyu) (FDC 174277)
- USDA FoodData Central: Miso (FDC 172442)
- Regulation (EU) No 1169/2011 on the provision of food information to consumers, Annex II (substances or products causing allergies or intolerances)
- Yamaguchi S.: The synergistic taste effect of monosodium glutamate and disodium 5′-inosinate, Journal of Food Science 32 (1967)
- H. McGee: On Food and Cooking (2004), kap. Seeds (Soy sauce and miso) a Fish and Shellfish (Fish sauces)